Mean radiant temperature

Online educational resource on achieving indoor environmental quality with radiant based HVAC systems
Not for profit educational resource on indoor environmental quality.
 Bookmark and Share
facts and myths on radiant barrier

What is Radiant Based HVAC?

See our new commentary for consumers on "Built to Code HVAC Systems"


See my article on MRT in Feb. 2013 Issue of HPAC.


"Since the mean radiant temperature has a considerable influence on man’s heat loss and thus on his state of comfort, its calculation is important in the detailed thermal analysis of a room..."
Fanger, P.O., Thermal Comfort: Analysis and Applications in Environmental Engineering, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1970


Journal of Industrial Hygiene, March 1932, pp., 95‐111, click to enlarge

A history lesson on radiant, Dr. Vernon, 1932, Journal of Industrial Hygiene, March 1932, pp., 95-111
Bookmark and Share


Definitions:

Mean Radiant Temperature Theoretical uniform surface temperature of an enclosure in which an occupant would exchange the same amount of radiant heat as in the actual non-uniform enclosure.

Operative Temperature

The uniform temperature of an enclosure in which an occupant would exchange the same amount of heat by radiation plus convection as in the actual non uniform environment.

Thermal Absorptance
Ratio of the radiant flux absorbed by a physical surface to that incident on it.

Thermal Emittance
A surface property of a material governing the emission of thermal radiation relative to that emitted by a perfect emitter, or black body, at the same surface temperature.


"For rooms in which all surfaces have a uniform temperature, the emittance has therefore no influence on the mean radiant temperature. If, on the other hand, there are significant temperature differences, the emittances will affect the relative influence on the mean radiant temperature of the various surfaces in the room." Fanger, P.O., Thermal Comfort: Analysis and Applications in Environmental Engineering, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1970


enclosure U values and MRT
Illustration showing the influence of building enclosure performance on thermal comfort and specifically the mean radiant temperature.


Click to enlarge operative temperature
Click above illustration showing an operative temperature using various combinations of dry-bulb temperature and mean radiant temperature.


Assessment of Mean Radiant Temperature in Indoor Environments

Assessment of Mean Radiant Temperature in Indoor Environments
citation: Tredre, B.E., Assessment of Mean Radiant Temperature in Indoor Environments,  Division of Human Physiology, National Institute for Medical Research, London, British Journal of Industrial Medicine, 1965 January; 22(1): 58–66.


Additional resources
Popular Topics
Advice for Consumers
Conduction Animation
Convection Animation
Duct Tape: Not For ducts
Effectiveness Coefficients
Earth Tube Heat Exch.'s
Energy and IEQ
Energy/Exergy Efficiency
Exergy & Sustainability
Filter Fist-a Cuffs
Floor Temperatures
Flooring R values
Flooring and Boiler Efficiency
Health and HVAC systems
Health and IEQ
Heated Hardwood Flooring
History of Radiant Heating
Human Factors
Human Thermal Plume
Humidity & the Environment
HVAC & Energy Efficiency 
IAQ Investigator
IEQ Research
Infiltration
Is slab insulation needed?
Mean Radiant Temperature
Moisture Monitoring
Operative Temperature
Paying for Downgrades
Radiant Animation
Radiant Based HVAC Guide
Radiant Cooling
Radiant Design Guide
Radiant Facts and Myths
Radiant Gone Wild
Radiant Mistakes to Avoid
Radiant Tube Depth: Effects
Reflective Insulation: Myths
Thermal Comfort
Thermal Comfort & IAQ
Thermal Comfort Survey
Thermal Manikins: Research
Thermography
Thermostats: Setback
Validating Designs
Water Heater Efficiency
Water Heaters as Boilers
Windows for Cold Climates
Walls for Cold Climates
Zoning a Building Guide
 

Definitions
IEQ

HVAC
Healthy Heating
Radiant based HVAC
Indoor ergonomics


We don't inhale comfort, we feel it through our skin. Inhalation is part of the respiratory process and relates to indoor air quality not thermal comfort.

Forced air system excel at conditioning the air, that is they are very good at:

decontamination,
deodorization and
de(humidification),

but radiant based HVAC systems excel at conditioning the skin for thermal comfort.


"Even though not in direct contact with the body, hot or cold objects still greatly affect our perception of temperature. This is because they emit and absorb radiant energy which activates the same sensory organs as conducted or convected heat." Dr. Andrew Marsh

"One square inch of skin contains up to 4.5m of blood vessels, the contents of which is heated or cooled before flowing back to influence the deep body temperature. Thus the close relationship between radiant energy and thermal comfort." Dr. Andrew Marsh

"As evidence of the importance of radiant heat exchange to the body’s thermal equilibrium, physiologists have discovered that living human skin has extraordinarily high absorptivity and emissivity (0.97), greater than almost any other known substance, matte-black metals included. Consequently, we are highly responsive to changes in mean radiant temperature."
Dr. Andrew Marsh


See overview of housing performance categories in North America.


"The more non-uniform a thermal field in a room, the greater the number of dissatisfied persons to be expected." Fanger, P.O., Thermal Comfort: Analysis and Applications in Environmental Engineering, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1970


"I say, if building codes dropped the reference to controlling air temperatures and switched the requirements to controlling mean radiant temperature, building performance specifications would have to change overnight.

Bad buildings have low MRT’s in winter and high MRT’s in summer; this contributes to large differences in the vertical air temperature; creates excessive drafts and increased radiant asymmetry. Bad buildings also have uncomfortable floor temperatures and are challenged to maintain reasonable levels of humidity." Bean, R., The Big Picture, Beyond the Benchmarks: Better Buildings, August 2011

  

Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part I
Copyright (c) 2010, Robert Bean, R.E.T., P.L.(Eng.) and www.healthyheating.com

For additional support visit our visitor services page.

Thermal Comfort: A Condition of Mind NEW!

Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part I: Introduction/theory
Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part II: Application of theory
Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part III: Spreadsheet tool for thermal bridging
Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part IV: Project examples & ASHRAE research
Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) - Part V: Calculation example (REHVA GB #7)
 


Have you ever considered that we don't feel the heat loss from the building, but the heat loss from our skin, ergo we must understand the intimate infrared relationship our bodies have with the surrounding surfaces of the room (Ts) described by the mean radiant temperature (Tr , Tmr or MRT). Mean radiant is a dominant element in the thermal comfort equation which is an integral part of indoor environmental quality (see also radiant asymmetry) and building performance.
 


simplified MRT

Figure 1. The mean radiant temperature (MRT) is a means of expressing the influence of surface temperatures on occupant comfort. It can be calculated many ways. In its simplest and least accurate form it is a homogenous steady state area weighted average of the uncontrolled or unconditioned surface temperatures (AUST) written as;

        Tmr = T1A1  + T2A2  + …+ TNA / ( A1  + A2  + …+ AN  )

where,

        Tmr = mean radiant temperature, R

        TN = surface temperature of surface N, R (calculated or measured)

       AN = area of surface

This method does not reflect the geometric position, posture and facing orientation of the occupant nor ceiling height nor the thermal comfort influence of extraordinary items such as cooled and heated surfaces.
 

MRT in reality

Figure 2. In practice the mean radiant temperature is ambiguous as the occupant moves about the space and as a result of different room geometries and changes to internal and external environmental conditions.
Bookmark and Share


Mean radiant temperature and the angle factor
In a more advanced review of MRT, we can not only look at the individual surface temperatures and their area but also the distance of those surfaces from the occupant and whether that person is seated or standing. Why is this important? Well let's say you live in a cold climate and have a home office where your back will be facing a large northern facing window. That large cold window will have much greater influence on your perception of comfort more so than any other surface in that room regardless of the air temperature.
Why? Because the radiant transfer from your warm body to that cold surface will invoke a cooling sensation from your back which will be perceived by your brain as being uncomfortable. The angle factor is a means to describe the geometric relationship an occupant has with each surface in the space.

When surfaces have a high emittance (ε), they can be assumed to be black and thus the following equation for mean radiant temperature can be used:
 

        Tmr4 = T14Fp-1  + T14Fp-1  + …+ TN4Fp-N

where,

        Tmr = mean radiant temperature, R

        TN = surface temperature of surface N, R

       Fp-N = angle factor between a person and surface N
 

When relatively small temperature differences exist between the surfaces of the enclosure the mean radiant temperature can be simplified to:
 

        Tmr = T1Fp-1  + T1Fp-1  + …+ TNFp-N


How does MRT fit in with thermal comfort?
Of course MRT is only one element of thermal comfort - and we would be naive to ignore the air temperature (dry bulb,
Tdb)...so the MRT and Tdb must be combined after factoring in their respective heat transfer coefficients into what is known as the operative temperature, written as:
 

        To = ( hrTmr + hcTdb ) / ( hr + hc )


Radiant based HVAC

We address the definition of radiant based HVAC systems throughout the site but suffice to say it is first and foremost the radiant influence as a result of the building enclosure and subsequent interior surface temperatures on the occupant. A low U-value enclosure will have warmer surfaces in winter and cooler surfaces in summer in comparison to an enclosure with higher U-values (ignoring discussions on internal gains). Because of the lower U-Value and reduced air leakage associated with a high performance building, there is lower heating and cooling loads and shorter periods of operating time. This leads to improved comfort and lower operating costs - both desirable for any building.

enclosure U values and MRT

Figure 3. Radiant based HVAC system begin with the building enclosure (U) where its thermal performance determines the interior surface temperatures and thus the mean radiant temperature (click image to enlarge).
Bookmark and Share


 

 

Figure 4. Mean radiant temperature can be controlled with enclosure performances as demonstrated above using FEA to model various walls.
Bookmark and Share


Building and energy codes, MRT and operative temperature (To)

Ironically, most building and energy codes do not explicitly consider thermal comfort from thermal comfort metrics such as mean radiant and operative temperatures  - if they did... the minimum requirements for insulation and air leakage would be better than it is currently specified. The few building codes which do consider the radiant element, usually place the description in the appendix and most enforcing authorities don't know the clauses exists. Here's a sample statement from the National Building Code of Canada v2010: Section A-5.3.1.2.(1) Use of Thermal Insulation or Mechanical Systems for Environmental Control;

“In addition to controlling condensation, interior surface temperatures must be warm enough to avoid occupant discomfort due to excessive heat loss by radiation.”


The above clause is not a trivial statement as it is one of the only places we have found in building codes in North America, which recognizes the intimate radiant relationship between thermal comfort and building surface temperatures. Virtually an entire industry of manufacturers, suppliers, builders and trades people incorrectly equate thermal comfort with air temperatures.


Relationships between mean radiant and dry bulb temperatures (Figure 5), floor surface temperatures and flux (Figure 6) for various operative temperatures.

Click for larger image: Operative temperature a function of mean radiant and dry bulb temperature

Figure 5 The sloped lines are the resulting operative temperatures with various combinations of mean radiant and dry bulb temperature (click image to enlarge).

 

click to enlarge

Figure 6. Relationship between heating flux and surface temperatures at various operative temperatures (click image to enlarge).
Bookmark and Share



The human body: a model for HVAC design

human comfort and mean radiant temperature
 

Figure 7. Your body already produces heat so it's only necessary to add or remove enough heat from a space to maintain a reasonable balance between the operative temperature and the occupant, and this can be accomplished very effectively first with a combination of architecture, interior design and then if needed high temperature radiant cooling and low temperature radiant heating systems.

 

Thermal comfort instruements
Figure 8. Thermal Comfort Instrumentation (Courtesy of Innova) - measures mean radiant temperature, dry bulb temperature, humidity, air velocity, radiant asymmetry and other metrics of the ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55 - Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy.
 

Bibliography:
1.       Fanger, P. O., 1972. Thermal Comfort, Analysis and application in Environment Engineering. New York. McGraw Hill
2.
       ASHRAE Fundamentals Handbook (2009), Chapter 9, Thermal Comfort
3.
       Matzarakis, A., Estimation and Calculation of the Mean Radiant Temperature within Urban Structures
4.
       Pearlmutter, D., Street Canyon Geometry and Microclimate

 

Bookmark and Share

Home | Seminars | Solutions | Heating Cafe | Contribute | Online Help | Bean's Blog | About Us | Glossary
Privacy Policy | Legal | Contact Us | Site Map |
Carlson-Holohan Award| Send Us Your Comments

Copyright © 2012 Healthy Heating. All rights reserved.1 2 3
Site developed by WebworX.ca
 
Donate using PayPal, Credit Cards Accepted